California's aid-in-dying law overturned in court

17 May, 2018, 06:24 | Author: Wade Massey
  • California's aid-in-dying law overturned in court

Superior Court Judge Daniel Ottolia ruled lawmakers illegally passed the law during a special session devoted to other topics.

Gov. Jerry Brown called the special session in 2015 to address Medicaid funding shortfalls. Life Legal Defense Foundation and the American Academy of Medical Ethics - both of which have affiliations with religious groups - led the way in challenging the law.

"The court made it very clear that assisted suicide has nothing to do with increasing access to health care and that hijacking the special session to advance an unrelated agenda is impermissible", Ms. Snyder said in a statement. Gen. Xavier Becerra said: "We strongly disagree with this ruling and the state is seeking expedited review in the Court of Appeal".

If the emergency appeal is denied, the law will be immediately struck down.

At least 111 terminally ill people, mostly suffering from cancer or neuromuscular disorders such as ALS and Parkinson's Disease, have used it to end their lives.

California is one of eight jurisdictions with legal protections for assisted suicide.

In January 2018, the California Catholic Conference reiterated its opposition to assisted suicide and criticized the lack of data collected and the lack of transparency of the law's implementation.

Last June, on the one-year anniversary of the law, Compassion & Choices estimated that at least 504 terminally ill adults have received prescriptions to end their lives based on inquiries to its consultation program.

The California law permits state residents who have been diagnosed with terminal illnesses and supposedly have less than six months of life remaining to receive a prescription from a physician for a lethal dose of drugs.

Modi beats Congress in key battleground
A similar "futile" exercise was done by Congress when the UPA II chose to divide Andhra Pradesh and carve out Telangana as a separate state just before the 2014 Lok Sabha polls.


Party will definitely form the government in Karnataka: BJP leader KS Eshwarappa
In Chickballapur, the BJP could not win any seat out of the five as in Kolar where it also scored zero out of six. They assumed it would be another case of Uttar Pradesh wherein the BJP made a clean sweep.


The US imposed sanctions against the leader of "Hezbollah" Sheikh Nasrallah
Specifically, OFAC, together with Gulf partners, designated Hasan Nasrallah, the Secretary General of Hezbollah. In addition, the sanctions reject the "false distinction" between the group's political and military wings.


"To be honest, a little bit surprised", Snyder said of the judge's ruling.

"We have seen more patients than we initially expected participating in the End of Life Option Act", said Harman, who was not involved in the lawsuit but has written about Stanford Health Care's experiences with the law.

It also noted that the law provided "no safeguards for labeled individuals who may suffer from untreated mental illness or mood disorders and grants full immunity for doctors to participate in the killing of their most vulnerable patients".

"We need government to promote the value of life, to support compassionate end-of-life care measures, and to empower doctors to aggressively treat pain-not to legalize ways to end patients' lives or save money by cutting healthcare short near the end of life", Dr. Stevens said.

Meanwhile, there's the other side of the equation: physician participation. "Choice is really an illusion for a very few", Stephanie Packer said, according to the Los Angeles archdiocese's Angelus News. She said assisted suicide is often framed as health care, but "nothing could be further from the truth". Before that, two doctors must have determined that the patient would die within six months and was mentally competent to choose death.

OR was the first to legalize physician-assisted suicide with a statute that took effect in 1998.

California is one of seven states, including Colorado, Hawaii, Montana, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington, along with the District of Columbia, that allow doctors to prescribe lethal prescriptions for terminally ill patients.

Assemblywoman Susan Talamantes Eggman, who backed the bill, charged that the judge's decision interfered with Californians in the process of securing the lethal drugs under the law.

Recommended:



Popular

How Does Boston Scientific Corporation (BSX) Stack Up Right Now?
From short-term to long-term calculations, you can see how it is presently going, and how would probably continue to move further. Finally, Jefferies Group reissued a "neutral" rating on shares of Boston Scientific in a research report on Friday, February 2nd.

Safety agency to investigate Tesla crash in Utah
Now the NHTSA is also announcing that it will investigate the accident, but only for data gathering as a "special crash". The vehicle was in Autopilot mode when it slammed into a concrete barrier that divided a busy Silicon Valley highway.

Police called to reports of rogue kangaroo on U.S. highway
That's how a deputy captioned a Facebook photo of a kangaroo in the road in McCormick County. Multiple Augusta-area outlets reported Tuesday afternoon that the kangaroo is back home.

Hilary Duff's Neighbor Plans to Sue the Star After Instagram's Attack
In a second clip, Duff continued: "We know your parents pay your rent, we know you've never worked a day in your life. But if you cross her, she'll call you out on social media, rallying her millions of followers to set you straight.

White House China hawk Navarro excluded from China trade talks
It sounds like, at least for these trade talks, you can take Navarro off that list of people on whom the president is leaning. Liu is now in Washington, D.C., for meetings and is expected to meet with White House officials Thursday and Friday.

Codemasters Reveals F1 2018 Release Date
The game will also include all of the official teams, drivers and circuits from the current 2018 season. We will look at Codemasters F1 2017 in a PC graphics performance and PC gamer way.

Girl, 11, killed when tree falls on vehicle in Newburgh
That being said, they still tend to be smaller than true tsunamis, which are usually triggered by earthquakes. Governor Andrew Cuomo declared a state of emergency for Putnam, Dutchess, Orange and Sullivan Counties.

Bobby Charlton leads tributes to 1966 victor Ray Wilson
He played in the last England team that had four, maybe five, world-class players... and he was certainly one of those. We shared some wonderful memories throughout our career and I had the pleasure of being his room-mate.

Triumvirate to run Air France-KLM for now after pay row
Departing CEO Janaillac told the shareholders' meeting that the group was facing "one of the worst crises in its history". Frédéric Gagey, who now seves as CFO at Air France-KLM, will become interim chairman of the Franco-Dutch group.

Barcelona great Andres Iniesta to decide 'next week' between China and Japan
Departing Barcelona legend Andres Iniesta says he will make a decision on the next step of his career "next week". Iniesta announced last month that he would be leaving Barcelona after 16 seasons.