Britain’s mass surveillance faulted by European rights court in landmark ruling

14 September, 2018, 17:10 | Author: Wade Massey
  • The case against the UK was brought by a group of journalists and rights activists

The judgement is not final, as it can be appealed to the grand chamber of the Strasbourg court.

However, the ECHR ruled that the processes used to share the intelligence with foreign governments was not in violation of privacy or human rights standards.

They concluded that the mass trawling for information by Britain's GCHQ spy agency violated Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights regarding the right to privacy because there was "insufficient oversight" of the programme.

The matter first came to light in 2013 when NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden revealed British surveillance practices-namely that the government intercepts social media, messages, and phone calls regardless of criminal record or suspicions of criminal activity.

The UK's bulk interception powers, exposed by the whistleblower Edward Snowden, have been found to be illegal by the European Court of Human Rights.

"While there is no evidence to suggest that the intelligence services are abusing their powers, the Court is not persuaded that the safeguards governing the selection of bearers for interception and the selection of intercepted material for examination are sufficiently robust to provide adequate guarantees against abuse", the Court's ruling stated.

Following the revelations, a group of 14 privacy and human rights groups headed by nonprofit Big Brother Watch brought claims against GCHQ, which were heard first in the UK's Investigatory Powers Tribunal - a special court set up specifically to hold intelligence agencies to account - and later in the European Court of Human Rights. The court also found that the system for obtaining communications data from service providers breached human-rights laws, but concluded the way the United Kingdom shares digital intelligence with foreign governments is legal. However, the ruling did find that individuals' privacy rights applied from the moment communications and data were captured by surveillance systems-not just when they were viewed or processed by human analysts.

"Once In A Lifetime" Hurricane Florence Weakens, Begins Lashing Eastern US
That's on top of the flooding, flying debris, and the other immediate storm-related events that can claim countless lives. The NHC went on to say that a few tornadoes could form in eastern and southeastern North Carolina into Friday.


Plane carrying body of Pakistani ex-PM Nawaz Sharif's wife reaches Lahore
For the sake of uninterrupted traffic flow, special arrangements were also made outside Jattiumra. A flight carrying Kulsoom Nawaz's casket landed in Lahore from London in the morning.


Hurricane Florence deluges Carolinas ahead of landfall
Officials said some 1.7 million people in the Carolinas and Virginia were warned to evacuate, but it's unclear how many did. Florence is expected to arrive in southeast North Carolina on Friday morning before drifting south into SC .


On the second point, the court noted particular concern about the way in which the government could search and examine this related data - the who, when and where of a communication - "apparently without restriction".

Following the Snowden revelations, the rules were replaced in November 2016 by the Investigatory Powers Act, a new law that effectively puts mass surveillance powers on a statutory footing.

Gavin Millar QC, also counsel for TBIJ, said: "The government must now rewrite the law as to how the security and intelligence service can look at and use journalists confidential communications and material".

The British government said it would give "careful consideration" to the court's findings.

Civil liberties campaigners who brought the case hailed the judgment as a landmark victory against the mass surveillance that governments have defended as an important tool in fighting terrorism.

"We will push on with our High Court challenge against the Investigatory Powers Act and I'm sure we'll draw on the judgement of today to explain why it means that act is also unlawful", she added.

Commenting on the ECHR's ruling, Silkie Carlo, director of Big Brother Watch, said: "This landmark judgment confirming that the UK's mass spying breached fundamental rights vindicates Mr Snowden's courageous whistleblowing and the tireless work of Big Brother Watch and others in our pursuit for justice".

Recommended:



Popular

Maurizio Sarri rules Manchester United and Tottenham out of title race
Luiz was frozen under Antonio Conte last season, which cost him a place in Brazil's squad to the World Cup in Russian Federation . As reported by Chelsea's official website , Luiz said: " First of all he's a great person, great as a human ".

European Parliament backs copyright changes
If they don't understand the rules, what hope the rest of us?" Critics have said the proposal amounts to a tax on links. Member of Parliament voted for the controversial rules with 438 votes in favor , 226 against and 39 abstentions.

US FDA Proposed Crackdown on Flavoured E-Cigs Puts Juul on Notice
The FDA has also been revamping its regulation on tobacco, including lowering the amount of nicotine in conventional cigarettes. The also gave dominant e-cigarette makers 60 days to explain how they plan to reverse the spike in use among minors.

The Impact Of Hurricane Florence
Florence is now churning through the Atlantic, only a few hundred miles off the coast of Wilmington, N.C. Is global warming to blame? The relationship between climate change and hurricanes is a complex one.

Tourists injured after rockfall at pristine beach in Greece's Zakynthos
There were no reports of missing people, one of the officials said, but authorities were combing land and sea as a precaution. O'Connell described the piece of rock that fell as being as big as a four-storey building, crashing down onto the beach .

Hurricane Florence begins to batter United States east coast
As if the storm itself is not unsafe enough, it is expected to spawn tornadoes in southeast North Carolina on Thursday and Friday. More than 80,000 people were already without power as the storm began buffeting the coast, and more than 12,000 were in shelters.

Celtics' Jabari Bird pleads not guilty to assault, kidnapping, strangulation
Bird has been at a local Massachusets hospital, where he is under guarded watch, since the alleged assault last Friday. New details have emerged surrounding the domestic abuse allegations facing Boston Celtics shooting guard Jabari Bird.

The new iPhone is confirmed in the gadget of two SIM-cards
As for other features, both the Xs and Xs Max will have a gold color option, as evidenced from the leaked marketing photo below. If history is any indication, iPhone Xs pre-orders will open up on Friday, September 14 ahead of a release on September 21.

This Insane Photo Of Hurricane Florence Is Going Viral
A video of the Category 2 Hurricane Florence has also been shared by NASA and it needs no introduction. It is expected start affecting North Carolina and SC as early as September 13.

Hurricane Florence weakens slightly as it moves toward US coast: NHC
Emergency declarations were in force in Georgia, South and North Carolina, Virginia, Maryland and the District of Columbia. Mr Cooper's office said the current emergency declaration was helping state officials prepare for the storm.